Category: Summary Judgment

Close up of Male lawyer or judge hand's striking the gavel on sounding block, working with Law books, report the case on table in modern office, Law and justice concept
California / Discovery / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Court Issues Final Orders Regarding Various Motions of Automotive Defendants

Jurisdiction: Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles

Defendants Mercedes-Benz USA LLC, Morse Tec LLC, and American Honda Motor Co. Inc. filed various motions for summary judgment, or in the alternative summary adjudication, against the plaintiff Samson Bareh’s claims that he was exposed to asbestos from their products. In addition, the defendant, Volkswagen Group of America Inc., filed a motion to compel discovery.

Mercedes-Benz filed a motion for summary adjudication of the strict liability, negligence, and fraud causes of action, as well as the …

Continue Reading
Judge chamber with gavel
Adjudication / California / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Summary Judgment and Adjudication Motions Filed by Three Automotive Product Defendants; Some Granted and Some Denied

Jurisdiction: Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles 

In this asbestos action, three defendants filed motions for summary judgment, and in some cases, in the alternative, motions for summary adjudication, against plaintiff Ronald Carpenter’s claims that he was exposed to asbestos from their products.

First, defendant ZF Active Safety US Inc. argued that plaintiffs had no evidence that Carpenter was exposed to any asbestos-containing parts from ZF Active Safety. Specifically, ZF Active Safety served interrogatories asking plaintiffs to identify people with knowledge that Carpenter was …

Continue Reading
The law concept background.
New York / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Defendant Denied Summary Judgment on Punitive Damages for Failure to Provide Case-Specific Support

Jurisdiction: Supreme Court of New York, New York County

Plaintiff Kevin Burns filed an asbestos-related lawsuit against numerous defendants, including Burnham, testifying that while he worked as a plumber he was exposed to asbestos insulation and rope from the removal and installation of Burnham boilers from approximately 1958 to the early 1980s.

Burnham moved for summary judgment on plaintiff’s punitive-damages claim, arguing that plaintiff failed to establish Burnham’s conduct rose to the level of egregious and morally culpable conduct necessary for an award of punitive damages. …

Continue Reading
Judge chamber with gavel
New York / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

ALCOA Denied Summary Judgment Where Question of Fact Exists

Jurisdiction: Supreme Court of New York, New York County

This action was filed on behalf of decedent, Kenneth Last, alleging he was exposed to asbestos while working for general contractor, ALCOA Inc., n/k/a ARCONIC Inc., at the World Trade Center during the 1970s. ALCOA filed a motion for summary judgment arguing the fire-proofing material used at the World Trade Center during decedent’s employment was non-asbestos containing.

The court notes that summary judgment is a drastic remedy and should only be granted if the moving party …

Continue Reading
Judge chamber with gavel
Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Defendant Shipyard Unsuccessful on Summary Judgment under 5th Circuit Precedent

U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana

Plaintiff Felton Robichaux brought this asbestos-related lawsuit claiming he was exposed to asbestos through his work as a land-based insulator and carpenter at Avondale Shipyard from 1961 to 1979. In January 2022, Robichaux was diagnosed with mesothelioma and filed the instant action in Civil District Court for the Parish of Orleans. Robichaux brought state law tort claims against Avondale. Because Robichaux was primarily exposed to asbestos while working on United States Navy ships at Avondale Shipyard, …

Continue Reading
The law concept background.
Punitive Damages / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Water Heater Defendant Obtained Partial Summary Judgment

Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles

In this asbestos action, defendant Rheem Manufacturing Company filed a motion for summary judgment, and alternatively summary adjudication, arguing that the plaintiffs do not have evidence that the relevant plaintiff was exposed to asbestos from Rheem products.

To show that a plaintiff cannot establish an element of a cause of action, a defendant must make the initial showing that the plaintiff does not possess, and cannot reasonably obtain, needed evidence. A plaintiff’s deposition testimony that he has …

Continue Reading
judge's gavel and books
Punitive Damages / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Supplier Defendant Succeeds in Opposing Punitive Damages

Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles

In this asbestos action, the court considered various defense motions.

Defendant Western Auto Supply company filed a request opposing punitive damages, arguing that the plaintiffs cannot prove that it acted with oppression, malice or fraud. Summary judgment or summary adjudication on the issue of punitive damages is proper only when no reasonable jury could find the plaintiff’s evidence to be clear and convincing proof of malice, fraud or oppression.

For a corporate defendant, the oppression, fraud or …

Continue Reading
Business and lawyers discussing contract papers with brass scale on desk
New York / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Judge Finds Question of Fact Regarding Boiler Manufacturer’s Warnings; Denies Motion for Summary Judgment as to Punitive Damages

Jurisdiction: Supreme Court of New York, New York County

In this asbestos-related lawsuit, the plaintiff alleged he was exposed to asbestos while working with, and around, boilers manufactured by defendant, Burnham, from 1961 to 1999.

Burnham filed a motion for partial summary judgment as to punitive damages, arguing the plaintiff failed to establish that Burnham’s conduct rose to the level of egregious and morally culpable conduct necessary for an award of punitive damages. According to Burnham, any exposure to asbestos by plaintiff through Burnham boilers were below …

Continue Reading
Wooden judge gavel, close-up view.
Florida / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Grant of Summary Judgment to Brake Manufacturer Reversed on Appeal

Court: Court of Appeal of Florida, First District 

The decedent, Joan Smith, died from mesothelioma allegedly caused by secondary exposure to asbestos through laundering her husband’s work clothing. From 1969 through 1993, Mr. Smith was employed as a mechanic and performed brake work on Mack heavy trucks. Mack did not manufacture its own brakes but rather purchased them from third-party suppliers, including Carlisle Industrial Brake & Friction. 

Carlisle acknowledged that it sold asbestos-containing brake linings to Mack from 1974 to 1979.  Mack, however, was only …

Continue Reading
Courtroom, Gavel And Law Books
New York / Summary Judgment
Posted by:

Power Companies’ Motion for Summary Judgment Denied

Court: Supreme Court of New York, New York County

Long Island Lighting Company (LILCO) is a subsidiary of Long Island Power Authority (LIPA). LIPA was created “to remedy LILCO’s conduct as a private electric provider” by closing LILCO’s Shoreham Nuclear Power Station — where the plaintiff-decedent was allegedly exposed to asbestos — and saving LILCO customers money by reducing utility costs. 

LIPA and LILCO moved for summary judgment on that basis that the plaintiff failed to (1) bring their claims within the statute of limitations …

Continue Reading